Our Team

 Dr. Toole is from Indianapolis and went to Holy Spirit grade school and Scecina Memorial High School. He attended Indiana University in Bloomington, where he earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Biology. He is a graduate of the Indiana University School of Dentistry.

Dr. Toole is a member of the American Dental Association, the Indiana Dental Association and the Indiana District Dental Society. 

He and his wife Carly have three sons: Liam, Elliott, and Gavin. His hobbies include music, wood-working, rock climbing and spending time with his family.

Amy is a graduate of Indiana University South Bend where she earned her Associates degree and later completed her Bachelor’s degree in Dental Hygiene. She had a lack of dental care growing up which inspired her to pursue a career in dental hygiene. She has a passion for educating patients about oral health.  When she is not in #teethland she is raising 3 kiddos in Franklin Township on the south side of Indy with her husband and best friend Mike.  She loves coffee, naps, twangy country music, wine, the crack of a softball bat, bundling up on a crisp fall day, taking the scenic route, the background noise of a football game (Go Bears!), a pedicure in peace, and the best of all is the sound of my kids laughing. 

 Elle grew up on the north side of Indy and completed her associates at Ivy tech, South Bend in 2023. She’s currently pursing her bachelors and has a love for helping others in optimizing their oral care needs.
After moving away for a couple years, Elle retuned back to Indiana with her fiancé, Declan, and their two cats. She loves to workout, tackle house projects, watch the packers, spend time with family, and eat healthy.
If dental hygiene has taught her anything, it’s taught her the importance of not only dental, but overall health and wellbeing. She hopes she can stress the same mentality to her patients as well.